July 26, 2008

Israelis and Fellow Travelers

By Ted Belman

About thirty years ago, my how time flies, I was listening to a lecture by an Israeli law professor who had represented Israel in negotiations with the Syrians after the ’73 war. To illustrate the difference in style between negotiators, he informed that when a customer walks into an Arab store, the Arab asks him how he is, to please sit down, can I get you a glass of water, where are you from etc., etc. When the same customer walks into an Israeli store, the Israeli says “Hello, what do you want?.. The Israelis are anxious to get down to business whereas the Arabs have all the time in the world. Current day Israeli negotiators should take a lesson from this.

Israelis are legendary for their brusqueness, rudeness or impatience however you want to term it. As a case in point, Israeli drivers have one hand on the steering wheel and one hand on the horn and don’t hesitate a second, to use it.. If you ever stood in line for a bus you will quickly learn to fight your way to the head of the line just as all Israelis do.

But that is a misleading picture. Native born Israelis are called sabras after a local fruit of the same name which is prickly on the outside and soft on the inside. That “softness” comes out in many ways. On two occasions when I was the last to get on the bus, because I hadn’t yet learned the art of getting to the front of the line, young Israelis gave up their seats for me and sat on the floor for the two hour trip ahead of us. In “My visit to Ein Harod” I told of the hospitality extended to me by my host and the hospitality extended to soldiers on a regular basis. A few weeks later my daughter and I were Shabbat guests at the home of a friend of hers. Israelis love to be hospitable. They are so happy to see you and welcome you to their country.

Many is the time I saw Israelis help people to cross the street or get on the buses with their packages when help is needed’ Just yesterday I asked a stranger how to call Toronto with my cell phone. We couldn’t figure it out on my phone so he lent me his cell phone to use. He wouldn’t let me repay him.

There are a few beggars around, not so many as to disturb your visit, and from what I have noticed they make a good living. Israelis are generous and empathetic.

Israel is a good place to live, except for the many reasons why it is not. In a recent poll among Arab Israelis, 74% said that they would rather live in Israel than any other country in the world. You read that right. Similarly, 74% of Jerusalemites, Arab and Jew, said they did not want Jerusalem to be divided. When the fence was being built, Israel was overwhelmed by requests from the Arabs affected to include them on the Israeli side. There were very few that wanted to be on the Arab side usually motivated by politics.

Before the advent of the peace process there was much commerce and intercourse between Arab and Jew in Judea and Samaria. Everyone benefited and was happy. These Arabs had the highest standard of living and education compared to Arabs in any Arab country. The peace process ruined everything. The Arab rulers and the western leaders just had to interfere.

There is a vibe in Israel that doesn’t exist in other countries. The country is young and growing. There is a sense of building something. There is a sense of future. The Oleh , Jewish immigrant, comes to Israel to participate in that endeavour. Just visit Ben Gurion Airport when a planeload of them arrive organized by Nefesh b’Nefesh. The excitement is palpable.

tednanahamed25.jpgAnd you don’t have to be Jewish to be caught up in it. One friend that I have made, Nana, is an American woman in her late thirties who has been here for a few months though she has a PhD from an American University. She has taken a year off and is thinking of making aliyah. She, too, feels the excitement of being part of a young country. She likes the sense of community and this gives added dimension to her work.

She introduced me to Hamed, her new friend, who is a Muslim refugee from Darfur and who taught himself to speak English. Hamed is a beautiful black man who has lived in Israel for about one years and devotes himself to running a very limited shelter for 150 plus Darfurian refugees. He receives no pay for his full time work. He told me of the day to day reality for Darfurians in Sudan and in Egypt where they are oppressed and killed by both governments. When they attempt to flee to Israel they are killed by Egyptian soldiers if seen before they reach Israel. So far this year Egyptians have killed 19 officially but Hamed tells me the count is much higher. Israel has allowed about 1,000 Muslim Darfurians and 2000 Christian Sudanese in. Their situation is difficult but paradise compared to life in Sudan.

Israel is an expensive country to live in. The cost of living in Tel Aviv is higher than in New York and much higher than in Toronto according to the latest statistics. Yet Israelis who earn less, get by, because they are not materialistic. As long as they have a roof over their heads and food on the table, they are happy. Forget about owning cars or an expensive wardrobe. Bus travel is cheap and convenient. A senior pays about $1.00 each way. Locally gown fruit and vegetables are inexpensive if bought in the Jewish Market in Jerusalem. Tomatoes and cucumbers cost $1.50 a kilo or 70 cents a pound. Fruit is about $1.20 a pound. Elsewhere these things are more expensive. Imported foods or toiletry is much more expensive as are cars.

The Health Care system in Israel is reputed as one of the most advanced in the world, and has many achievements in the fields of the medicine and the medical study, health of the public and accessibility of the public to the health services. Thousands of “medical tourists” travel to Israel every year to take advantage of its state-of-the-art medical system. Even with the cost of flights and hotel, in vitro fertilization and cancer care in Israel costs far less than in the U.S. or Europe. Anyone can purchase healthcare for a low fee. It is graduated according to income. Pre-existing conditions or age is not a bar. The Ministry of Foreign Affairs tells the whole story.

It’s a small world, as they say, even smaller for Zionists. One of the places that I frequent is M-Central which serves as a home for international journalists. Lectures and information are provided to them. M-Central has interns from the English speaking world, usually young people who are intent on making aliya, who work with them. Much to my surprise one of them was the daughter of a friend of mine in Toronto.

Just recently, I attended a lecture at the JCPA by Amb (ret) Yoram Ettinger, who I know well,. One of the interns I met there was the daughter of a Washington insider that I met last year in Washington and with whom I now keep in touch. She too was making aliya.

Then I couldn’t help but notice another intern, Miranda, an American from Virginia, who is making aliya in a year. She was beautiful and black. I was intrigued. She was the daughter of a Lithuania Jewish mother and a black American father and she was a committed Zionist. She has one more year to go in Virginia to get a degree in Middle East Studies and intends to complete her Masters in Israel. She was a delight to talk with.

Yoram was there to talk about the AIDRG Study which concluded that the number of Arabs in Judea and Samaria has been over represented by one million. The net result of which is that there is no demographic time bomb and that the Jews out number the others 2:1. He is a man on a mission. He makes this presentation 2 to 3 times a day, often one on one. He has even presented to members of Congress. The word is slowing getting out. The importance of this study is that it takes the pressure off the need to rush to a settlement and it opens up other options for discussion, such as annexing Judea and Samaria.

One of the suggestions Yoram made was that Israel further expand Jerusalem’s borders to the Dead Sea in the east and Gush Etzion in the south. In the expanded area the ratio of Jews to Arabs would remain at 2:1. He is a believer in the benefits of modern infrastructure. He wants high speed trains and modern roads to service this area which will attract industry and people. It will also lower real estate prices for all. He even suggests the construction of an international airport in the city. Cheap housing could be built at the north end of the Dead Sea which would only be a 15 minute train ride to Jerusalem. He suggested that a town planner should draw up such a plan. As it so happens, a young architect friend of mine, Eric, who speaks Hebrew, just got his Masters in town planning. He is now visiting Israel and I have asked him to draw up such a plan and he is all for it. No political considerations would apply. He too may make aliya.

Jerusalem is located fourteen miles West of the Dead Sea and thirty-three miles East of the Mediterranean. Bethlehem lies about five miles to the SE. The city is situated on an uneven rocky plateau at an elevation of 2,550 feet. It is 3,800 feet above the level of the Dead Sea. Note those distances well. The Mediterranean is less than 50 miles from the Dead Sea. Approaching Jerusalem from the east requires an ascent in a short distance of 2500 feet. Jerusalem is surrounded by other hilltops on which large suburbs have been built.. The valleys below are generally undeveloped..

It is Shabbat now and I am enjoying it in beautiful Ein Kerem where I am staying for the summer. It is a suburb of Jerusalem. I might add that there is no public transportation in Jerusalem on Shabbat but that’s okay. Nothing wrong in just hanging out and enjoying the view and the neighborhood..

Posted by Ted Belman @ 10:37 am | 11 Comments »

11 Responses to Israelis and Fellow Travelers

  1. 4infidels says:

    Ted,

    Thanks for the wonderful report. Wish I was there!

  2. Joseph Alexander Norland says:

    This “man-on-the-spot account” is worth it’s metaphorical weight in gold. Please, Ted, continue posting these reports.

  3. VinceP1974 says:

    I loved walking around in the Old City. I did get dirty looks from some Arabs sometimes because I was told I had an Israeli look to me. I would just make sure to say a few words to people and they would figure out I was an American, and then you can see the cash register ring in their eyes.

  4. Ted Belman says:

    Short and sweet emails rec’d

    Thank you so much Mr. Belman for your enlightening and from the heart emails. For me they are a blessing.

    Thank you Ted for a beautifully written article.

    Miranda should be the subject of an in depth profile that we can post. Can you get a picture & interview her?

    Very nice article.

    I like your style. Good job, from The Golden State. –
    CA Director, Republican Jewish Coalition

    This is so wonderful to read, Ted! Sending it on to friends who will travel to Israel for the first time in October –

    And, it makes me want to make aliyah with my daughter, Hartlee, who enjoyed seeing you! Regards to Aryeh, and see you in Toronto –

    Interesting travelogue. Thank you, Ted.

    thanks for your email. I totally agree with you. I am Jew , English, living in Spain since 61. A staunch Zionist, but would never live in Israel for those reasons. The bus quue, having your toe stepped on.. Why was your foot in the way?…but i love israel and the Israelis. May they never change… Except ..maybe .. A sorry once in a while… Israel, as the T shirt says… whereever you stand.. i stand.

    Re: “Even with the cost of flights and hotel, in vitro fertilization and cancer care in Israel costs far less than in the U.S. or Europe.”

    How do they do this? I know some state legislators who might be interested in how Israel’s health care system delivers such advanced care at low cost.

    Thanks once again for the very insightful & meaningful view & description of what’s happening. Really great to see that you are loving the experience. I can hear it in every word you write. Shavua Tov. Stan

    Loved your article and learned some new things about Israel’s geography. I was already aware of their “crusty” personality. Would that some of the Israeli’s penchant for welcoming visitors would somehow rub off on Canadians. We could use more of that. Your smile in the picture tells it all. You are obviously having a wonderful summer. Stay well and be safe.

    Fine choice, Ein Kerem. Hope you drive out to the monastery at neighboring Even Sapir and take a dip. From there you can ramble along the hill separating Sapir and Aminadav, along which are a handful of natural pools. It’s a lovely and inspiring walk along then up and round to Yad Kennedy.

    Lived there 18 months while working at jpost.com. Don’t miss the paper, but ah, the place! Not that you need a reminder, but I sometimes did that we are very lucky and privileged to be born who we are and at these times.

    Since you are in Israel your writing is even more beautiful and the spirit of the land is
    getting at you!!!
    Keep writing and …It will be a good idea to stay there!!! Tov meod!

    Hi Ted…
    These are wonderful missives — I think you’ve got a book in the making! Love the detail and the bite-size historic notes…also the photos. Keep the cards and letters coming… All the best…cheers..peter

    Thank you so much for you email letter. I am not Jewish but I truly love the people of Israel and your emails bless my heart and teach me a great deal. I have never been to Israel, but I’m saving my money that I might see and meet
    in person the People and Land of Israel.

  5. Max says:

    I like to read your personal reports, impressions and anecdotes of being in Israel.

  6. davidstill says:

    Very nice. Are you now a full-time citizen of israel, living there instead of Canada? Why not?
    Though I ardently support Israel, you do not note the poverty that many are facing and for whom little is being done, nor the Russian immigrants who now prefer to relocate in Germany (!) rather than Israel.

  7. Laura says:

    davidstill, why are you such a negative prick when it comes to Israel?

  8. yamit82 says:

    davidstill,


    Though I ardently support Israel,
    you do not note the poverty that many are facing and for whom little is being done, nor the Russian immigrants who now prefer to relocate in Germany (!) rather than Israel.

    You are kidding RIGHT?

  9. BlandOatmeal says:

    Yamit,

    Take a hike. You seem to think the whole world is against you. You have consistently attacked every friend of Israel who doesn’t share your kooky, ersatz ideas. You’re a disgrace to your people, and I’m grateful all Jews aren’t like you. I wish you would take your bigoted, small mind and go post somewhere else — maybe on STORMFRONT. Those folks would love you — they’re just like you.

  10. yamit82 says:

    Bland

    Take a hike. You seem to think the whole world is against you. You have consistently attacked every friend of Israel who doesn’t share your kooky, ersatz ideas. You’re a disgrace to your people, and I’m grateful all Jews aren’t like you. I wish you would take your bigoted, small mind and go post somewhere else — maybe on STORMFRONT. Those folks would love you — they’re just like you.

    I do not think the world is against me and I don’t normally have paranoiac proclivities.

    Have I attacked you? I don’t recall attacking you. Some Jews posting here maybe but thats within the tribe so we more or less are used to our family tiffs. But friends? can you be specific? You have denigrated constantly my faith and I yours I would call that even. I unlike you understand from where your ideas and beliefs are founded so I have never taken offense personally till now. I think you are accustomed to a certain kind of Jew and you haven’t had much contact with many Jews who are not supplicant and kiss ass to WASPS and who may feel a little bit uneasy in your circles but would never be so bold to tell it to your face. You say you are a friend to Israel, Jews or both, not clear. How or in what way are you a friend? Can we depend on you? In what way? You tell me so even a kook like me might understand; in what way are you a friend? and in what way have I attacked you or our friends? I have attacked missionaries, but not our Buddhist and Hindu friends. Not our cousins the Ishmaelites except those who are trying to kill us and me. I do have a number of close acquaintances from the local Arabs, some employees and I have been a guest in their homes and they mine,We have learned to understand one another over the years. They are almost like tribal family, just different tribe.You call me a bigot, I call it ethnocentric. I don’t have your illustrious genealogy, but I can trace my fathers side of the family back to the personal body guard of King David.

    Yes, I am a Jew, and when the ancestors of the Right Honorable gentleman were brutal savages in an unknown island, mine were priests in the temple of Solomon.
    Benjamin Disraeli
    Reply to a taunt by Daniel O’Connell.

    Now how am I a disgrace to my people? What do you specifically consider are my kooky, ersatz ideas? You probably are correct to some extent here but I would like to hear them spelled out by you anyway. Small mind, now that is insulting, I can handle bigot and kooky but now you have attacked my mind..Well I won’t give in to my baser urges and search for some childish put down but I could you know.

    and lastly I am not acquainted with stormfront but as you are send me a link and I will take a peak at it.

    one last thought bland; wouldn’t this be a dull world and dull blog if we all agreed and thought alike? I have not attacked you personally but you have me. In the end I don’t really care what you think of me or anything else here.

  11. Pingback: Israpundit » Blog Archive » “Black is Beautiful”