Christmas Day musings, Part I

Christmas Day musings, Part I

In an article published on December 21, the JPost reported about a recent study released by the UN sewer, in which Israel was blamed for the deteriorating situation of Christians in Bethlehem. JPost quotes the UN sewer as saying:

Since 1993, however, it [the UN study - Ed] said, measures taken by Israel to provide security to its population have restricted Bethlehem's Christian and Muslim worshippers from accessing their holy sites in Jerusalem.

"Restricting access to Jerusalem's and Bethlehem's holy sites runs the risk of aggravating religious divisions in an area that has historical and religious importance for those of the Christian, Muslim and Jewish faiths alike," the report said.

It would appear that Christians throughout the Moslem world are living in a state of bliss, and the only place where Christian worshippers are restricted, is Bethlehem, a consequence of Israel's actions.

The alternative explanation is that the UN sewer is continuing with its obsession of maligning Israel, while ignoring the real discrimination and persecution that are meted out to Christians in the Moslem world.

A glance at a few AP/Reutres headlines published recently substantiates this claim:

Dec 7, Reuters: "Gunmen Attack Armenian, Chaldean Churches in Mosul".

Dec 8, AP: "Police, Christians battle over alleged forced conversion to Islam".

Dec 23, AP: "Christians in Indonesia Move Underground".

These headlines, of course, do not represent a systematic study, but rather a random collection of links that happened to land on my desk.

A rigorous analysis of the situation was presented by Prof Paul Merkley in his articles and books, some of which were highlighted in IsraPundit postings (enter "merkley" in our search engine, middle of right-hand column, to find these articles). In his book, "Christian attitudes towards the state of Israel", Prof Merkley notes that while the percentage of Christians in all Middle East countries but Israel is dwindling, the percentage of the Christian population in Israel has remained steady at about 3%. Israel is among the few Middle East country where Christians may worship openly and in complete freedom. (The reference to Prof Merkley's book is:

Merkley, Paul Charles. Christian Attitudes towards the state of Israel. Montreal: McGill-Queens University Press, 2001.)

Contrast the situation of Israel's Christians with that of Christians in Saudi Arabia, for example. An AP news story published on Dec 23 under the title "Where Is Christmas in Saudi Arabia?" reports:

Saudi Arabia has stated publicly that its policy is to protect the right of non-Muslims to worship privately. However, Defense Minister Prince Sulta also stressed that the kingdom would never allow churches to be built.

Earlier this year, Sheik Ibrahim al-Ghaith, chief of the powerful religious police, said Saudi Arabia would never allow public displays of non-Muslim faith.

The State Department said in 1993 that "non-Muslim worshippers risked arrest, lashing and deportation for engaging in overt religious activity that attracts official attention."

...

The bans go beyond Christian symbols. Small statues of Buddha are confiscated at airports, and Buddha pictures on a popular CD have been colored over. Ironically, a CD of Gregorian chants sitting next to it was left untouched.

...

Religious police agents become very active in the days leading up to Christian and Western celebrations. A few weeks ago, a toy store owner was detained for promoting witchcraft because he carried such Halloween decorations as scary masks and witches' hats.

That is why Christmas cards are sold under the counter and only in very few stores.

But the UN has nothing to say about this religious oppression, save perhaps, to vote Saudi Arabia to the UN Human Rights Commission for another term (Saudi Arabia is a member of the Commission for the period 2004-2006 - good enough for Ripley's "believe it or not") . Indeed, even the State Department took its time -- over decades -- before it listed Saudi Arabia among the violators of freedom of religion.

In an imitation of Apartheid customs, Saudi Arabia erected large road signs on the way to Mecca, warning non-Moslems to leave the route to Mecca. You can see a photo of the sign at LGF.

All this is a propos of the UN complaint about freedom of religion in Israel/Yesha. Tomorrow, I will post excerpts from a very unique book, written by Carmen Bin Laden (yes, Osama's sister in law). She goes into the issues of women's oppression in great detail.


Posted by Joseph Alexander Norland at December 25, 2004 08:06 AM


Comments

1. Dr. E. Metzler-Moziani, Judge (ret.) said:

Thank you, Joseph Alexander Norland, for posting this excellent article. Let me add a link to the website of the U.S. Department of State, Bureau of Public Affairs, International Religious Freedom Report Home Page, Released on September 15, 2004, entitled "Saudi Arabia, International Religious Freedom Report 2004, Released by the Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor"

It's about time for the Free World, which stands for Religious Freedom, to take action against Islam, the cutthroat killer religion, committed to destroy our open society, on which they have declared Holy War on September 11, 2001, to enforce the Principle of International Reciprocity which demands: No mosques in the USA, Canada, Europe, and the whole Free World, as long as Saudi-Arabia bans Churches and Synagogues in Arabia! -- To hell with Sowdyism and the 9-11 Sowdy scum.

Thus, the Grand Mosque in Rome, Italy, must be closed immediately until Islam allows a Roman Catholic cathedral to be built for the archbishop of Mecca and Medina, and likewise a Synagogue for the Chief Rabbi of Saudi Arabia. As long as Christians and Jews are banned by Islam, Islam must be banned in the West.

Islam has taken shamelessly advantage of our Religious Freedom, while denying it to us in return. Therefore, Reciprocity must be enforced!

Outlaw Islam, the killer religion! -- Stop Islamic Subversion! -- No mosques in the U.S.A., unless Churches and Synagogues are allowed in Saudi Arabia!


Posted by: Dr. E. Metzler-Moziani, Judge (ret.) on December 25, 2004 03:40 AM

2. BobW [TypeKey Profile Page] said:

A absolutely perfect example for a decisive leveraged parry !

The Bethlehem situation should be developed to the hilt ! Can we imagine a fact-finding tream from the American south visiting Bethlehem and reviewing the UN "study" while reviewing the situation in person?!

Since Bethlehem is scheduled to become part of the new """Palestine""", there will be more restrictions than today. I do not believe most American Christians understand or know about the situation.

I join Dr Metzler-Maziani in suggesting the UN's view of "religion" has been ignored. Jews must be free to access holy sites in Saudi Arabia and Lebanon. A well-focused publicity campaign could remind Roman Catholics that Libya's former Italian Cathedral of the Sacred Heart of Jesus has been converted to the Mosque of Gamal Abdel Nasser.

Another fact-finding team, perhaps from California to Vancouver, BC, can ask why the UN allows member states like Indonesia and Malaysia to legally prohibit conversions from Islam to Christianity. The Southern Baptist Missionary Board would surely have an interest in a copy of the report.

We do not operate under a plan thus we lose easy opportunities. First, what is needed is a diaspora Jewish organization.

I close by wishing a Merry Christmas to Christian readers.

Kol tuv,
BobW

Posted by: BobW [TypeKey Profile Page] on December 25, 2004 07:10 AM

3. Ed D said:

When in Rome, do as the Romans do, only the Israelis need to do it better.

Posted by: Ed D on December 25, 2004 09:49 PM

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)