Old Prejudices Revived

Old Prejudices Revived

By Roz Rothstein

Throughout October, a largely unseen wave of anti-Semitism has been washing up across North America in a series of conferences run by a Jerusalem-based organization called the Sabeel Ecumenical Liberation Theology Center,

At gatherings in Chicago and Cedar Rapids, Iowa, Sabeel-trained speakers have demonized Israel, with similar speeches expected later this month at their conferences in Denver and Toronto. Started by Palestinian Christians in 1989, Sabeel does not promote peace or a genuine understanding of the Middle East conflict but instead musters support for punishing Israel through divestment campaigns, part of its larger goal of dismantling Israel to make way for a Palestinian-dominated one-state solution.

I attended the two-day Sabeel conference held at Chicago’s Lutheran School of Theology, where I witnessed intolerance and prejudice against Jews and the Jewish State. I did not think I would witness this in America’s third largest city, especially at the close of yearlong celebrations of the 350th anniversary of the arrival of Jews in America and only 65 years after the Holocaust.

The Oct. 7-8 gathering in Chicago attracted about 200 people. At the conference, Palestinian activist George Rishmawi actually claimed that Israel uses a poison gas that weakens the muscles of Palestinian demonstrators so they can’t run away, and that the IDF quickly retrieves the canisters so that no one can identify the gas. This echoed of the blood libel stories that have caused Jews so much suffering in the past.

I wish people of good faith had been with me to hear the relentless litany of historical distortions and slander. Michael Tarazi , a Harvard-educated attorney and former advisor to Palestinian leaders, accused Israel of starting all the Arab-Israeli wars, saying Israel probably withdrew from Gaza because Israel has, “depleted all the usable drinking water.”

Tarazi also warned audience members, “not to be side-tracked from divestment from companies who do business in Israel by those who want to have dialogue about this.” Instead, he urged people to, “stick to your convictions because there is no point to having dialogue with people you disagree with.”

There were also a couple of Jewish presenters including professor Marc Ellis of Baylor University . Describing himself as an “outrageous Jew,” Ellis compared Israel to Nazi Germany, attacked some progressive Jews as racists, and claimed that Jews had taken the “wrong lesson from the Holocaust.”

He also showed photos of two of Judaism’s holiest objects, the Ark that holds the Torah and also a Torah scroll, both defaced by superimposed images of Apache helicopters. He said that this is what he thinks of when he looks at arks and Torahs.

Perhaps the well-meaning Christians who attended this event have not researched how the Sabeel center tries to give religious justification to, and also Christian support for, a radical Palestinian agenda. In 2001, Sabeel’s founder, the Anglican Rev. Canon Naim Ateek , wrote that, “Jesus is on the Cross again with thousands of crucified Palestinians around him…The Israeli government crucifixion system is operating daily.”

In 2005, Ateek said that Palestinians suffer as Jesus did: “We had the Contemporary Way of the Cross, the Via Dolorosa for Palestinians…These are the demolished homes, destroyed villages, checkpoints. Every one of those is a station of the cross, a station of suffering.” Such anti-Semitic images of deicide were thought to have been buried with the Holocaust, after which many Christian churches repudiated such rhetoric. But at the Sabeel conference in Chicago, no one asked Ateek to retract words he has used to degrade Judaism and Jews.

Throughout the Chicago talks by Ateek and his allies, the audience simply nodded, as though agreeing with the noxious statements and attacks. No one asked searching questions. No one sought out Israel’s side of the story, about the terrorist campaign that Israel has been trying to fend off, about how there cannot be reconciliation if Palestinian leadership does not accept genuine responsibility for terrorism or even accept Israel’s right to exist, or about how moderation and peace cannot emerge from such hateful presentations at Sabeel conferences.

Sabeel’s North American backers have organized the conferences in Cedar Rapids, Denver and Toronto. I fear that other well-meaning audiences will be deceived by Sabeel’s cloak as a Palestinian Christian group seeking peace, and thus unwittingly sponsor Sabeel’s hate-filled, deceptive programs.

Many Israeli policies can be criticized. But unwarranted is to have Israel maligned with echoes of old anti-Semitic canards and also hear Israel’s humanitarian efforts and reasonable compromises either ignored or twisted.

I am saddened to see such ugly rhetoric given free rein in America. How troublesome to see Christians sit quietly as Sabeel’s misguided friends speak in their name.

But mostly, I am sad to see such hatred erupting again, as it bodes badly for us all.

Roz Rothstein is national director of the non-profit Israel advocacy group StandWithUs, which in September premiered its 50-minute documentary, “Tolerating Intolerance: Hate Speech on Campuses.” StandWithUs is also a member of The Coalition for Responsible Peace in the Middle East.

Posted by Ted Belman at October 27, 2005 04:43 AM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.israpundit.com/mt-tb.cgi/10995


Comments

1. Bill Narvey said:

Naim Ateek's and the Sabeel Foundantion's pro-Palestinian and anti-Israel reputation is as well known as their reputation for resorting to anti-semitic views to make their points.

Why then did Chicago's Mayor welcome them to his city? While much ire has been expressed in blog forums such as Israpundit in this regard, what if any efforts have been made to take the Mayor to task and what if any consequences will befall the Mayor for his having done so?

With the Sabeel conference in Chicago drawing a meagre 200 attendees, it begs the question as to whether that number is representative of the extent of the support Naim Ateek and his Sabeel Foundation have worldwide?

Surely, the Mayor's office would have had some information at least as to the kinds of crowds the Sabeel Foundation drew in the past in other places. A small draw and likely just from the host city for the conference provides no economic benefit to the city that hosts conferences that draw thousands from elsewhere.

I am left scratching my head all the more as to why the Mayor saw fit to welcome Naim Ateek and his organization to Chicago?

The Chicago Mayor should be grilled and roasted on these matters, but by the same token the Mayors of Cedar Rapids, Denver and Toronto should have their feet put to the fire as well if they had any hand in welcoming or permitting the Sabeel conference to take place in their cities.

Roz Rothstein reports that some of the views on the Israel-Palestinian conflict expressed at the Chicago Sabeel conference were as expected, anti-semitic. To that extent the speakers addressing the attendees were engaging in disseminating and inciting hate and from Ateek's and the Sabeel Foundations reputation that preceded them, that would have been anticipated.

Being forewarned gives one the opportunity to be forearmed.

I wonder whether authorities charged with the responsibility to investigate hate crimes and lay charges when apprporiate, were present to tape record and otherwise monitor the views expressed at the Sabeel Conference? If not, why not?

In both the U.S. and Canada we have heard and read about a number of instances over the years where anti-semitic views were expressed in public forums usually by representatives of various pro-Palestinian Muslim organizations. To my knowledge, No charges were ever laid. Not even a slap on the wrist with the advisory caution to be nice and don't do it again was given.

It seems that in both Canada and the U.S., the lawful limits on free speech, when it comes to expressing pro-Palestinian views are ignored.

Two notable exceptions in Canada where authorities did act involved Ernst Zundel the Jew hating Holocaust denier and David Ahenakew the Jew hating Holocaust justifier who were charged and convicted. Then again they were not expressing views on the Israel- Palestinian conflict and to my knowledge none of the purveyors of Jew hatred views in the context of the Israel Palestinian conflict have ever been charged with a hate crime.

I wonder what Toronto authorities are doing to investigate the Sabeel conference as it unfolds in Toronto? If history is any indication, Toronto authorities will do absolutely nothing.

Posted by: Bill Narvey on October 27, 2005 09:48 AM

2. BobW said:

Shalom Bill,

Re your para 1, just follow the money.

Kol tuv,
Bob

Posted by: BobW on October 27, 2005 11:29 AM

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)