Support Israpundit




February 14, 2008

PA wants all of Jerusalem

By Ted Belman

Khaled Abu Toameh , writing in THE JERUSALEM POST, advises that a PA official says Jerusalem talks taking place openly and secretly – PA insists gets Ramat Eshkol, French Hill

    “This means that the negotiations with the Israelis are taking place both openly and secretly.”

    Abdel Qader dismissed the idea that Israel would retain control of some parts of east Jerusalem. “Our position is, ‘Take it all or leave it,’” he said. “We have also made it clear to the Israelis that we won’t accept any partial solutions for Jerusalem. As far as we are concerned, Jerusalem must be one geographic, political and religious unit.”

    He said the parties were still trying to reach an agreement over which Jerusalem they were talking about – the city that’s mentioned in United Nations General Assembly Resolution 181 in 1947, the one that was occupied in 1967 or the one that was expanded by Israel afterward. “On this issue, there hasn’t been any progress yet,” he said.

    Abdel Qader said the negotiations were not only focusing on the Arab part of Jerusalem, but on its west as well. “There are Jews who say they have rights and property in the eastern part of Jerusalem, and that’s fine with us,” he said. “At the same time, there are Arabs who have a lot of property in the western section of Jerusalem. So the talks are not only over the eastern

    As for Shas’s threat to quit the coalition over the negotiations on Jerusalem, the PA official said he could not understand why the haredi party was upset.

    “Shas is not new to Israeli politics,” he said. “I can’t understand why they’re so upset. What did they think, that peace could be achieved without [dividing] Jerusalem? Have they forgotten that [then-prime minister] Ehud Barak already offered us large parts of Jerusalem at the Camp David summit [in 2000]?”

If only Israel was so emphatic about keeping it all. When your opponent states his position so categorically, the fact that you continue discussions suggests that you might give them what they want. Why doesn’t our government say equally that Jerusalem will remain ours, all of it. At least that balances the positions.

Meanwhile Olmert says we are not discussing Jerusalem and Livni says we are. Shas on the other hand is all over the place. Shas now says that they will bolt when discussions commence but mean when official discussions commence. Meanwhile unofficial discussions will be going on.

Then there is the issue of the “right of return”. The PA has been equally categorical on insisting on it and Israel is prepared to make some kind of concession regarding it. Furthermore the PA has refused to recognize Israel as a “Jewish state” as distinguished from a “Jewish homeland”.

Either Olmert has no bottom line or he does in which event he knows there will be no agreement since Livni has advised in writing that “until there is an accord on every issue there will be no accord on any issue”. If the former, Olmert should be removed from office. If the latter, Olmert is only negotiating for show as preferable to aborting the process.

Posted by Ted Belman @ 10:43 am | 4 Comments »

4 Responses to PA wants all of Jerusalem

  1. Give ‘em the Sudetenland, and they’ll be wanting Czechoslovakia and Poland next… Didn’t the world learn anything from 1938-1939?

  2. yamit82 says:


  3. Teshuvah says:

    Give them Bush’s Texas ranch.

  4. NormanF says:

    Of course… Ehud Olmert can’t give the PA the Western Wall or the Jewish neighborhoods of Jerusalem. If he can’t concede on that, no division of Jerusalem can happen. He could sign over the rest of Israel to Mahmoud Abbas tomorrow and there would be peace of sorts… no Israel. An Islamofascist’s wet dream.

Israpundit Digest

Support Israpundit





Blog Traffic

Pages|Hits |Unique

  • Last 24 hours: 20,245
  • Last 7 days: 145,066
  • Last 30 days: 336,682
  • Online now: 63
Los Angeles SEO

Recent Comments

  • There is No Authentic Right in Israel (29)

    • dweller: @ yamit82: “Breaths were held Monday night… [etc]…Finally, the...

    • yamit82: dweller Said: Vengeance indeed — GOD‘s vengeance. His wrath, His...

    • yamit82: dweller Said: — “rational” indeed. Who would think that YAMIT would...

    • dweller: @ yamit82: “What is the real Meaning of Passover for the Jews?...

    • dweller: @ yamit82: “The majority of the world has a wrong...

  • Obama Plans to Return Looted Jewish Artifacts To Iraq (10)

    • CuriousAmerican: Thanks, Ted. This site lays out legal strategies to get the...

    • Ted Belman: @ the phoenix:I do not believe that CA is an antisemite. I find...

    • CuriousAmerican: For you information: Phoenix You had better believe people...

    • CuriousAmerican: Ignoring Phoenix’s foul mouthed outburst and moving...

    • CuriousAmerican: What is your problem? Did I say suing for property is wrong?...

  • Can Israel be both Jewish and democratic (180)

    • dweller: @ dove: Asked and answered (and more than once). “Why couldn’t...

    • dweller: @ yamit82: “Yeshua and His disciples never taught about the day of...

    • Ted Belman: @ AbbaGuutuu:Please desist from discussing Jesus on this site or...

    • dweller: @ honeybee: “[Democratic values] have only been around and tested...

    • dweller: @ yamit82: @ yamit82: “Veritas Vos Liberabit” You know...

  • US Government Promoting Islam in Czech Republic (9)

    • Mickey Oberman: I clicked too soon in No. 1, See my correction in No. 2 ....

    • honeybee: yamit82 Said: 4 mandatory cups of wine then 4 more then some Cheves...

    • honeybee: @ yamit82: Watching the Battle of the Bundy’s on Megan...

    • honeybee: yamit82 Said: grandchildren Ah you have grandbabies, your tribe has...

    • yamit82: honeybee Said: You’re home early and from all your posts on this...


Fair Use

This site may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of political, human rights, economic, democracy, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research, educational, or satirical purposes. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Site Membership

Google Site Search


    Ted Belman


    News and Views on Israel, the Middle East, the war on terror and the clash of civilizations.


Will Israel attack Iran

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...



Iran islam



Daily Archives

April 2014
« Mar    

Selected Israpundit Articles


Miscellaneous Info

    All Politic Sites