Support Israpundit




June 11, 2007

Jewish Israel is the key to its survival, not its end

By Ted Belman

Jerry Gordon writes Burg goes ballistic: paints Israel as “Zionist ghetto” because he said to define the State of Israel as a Jewish state is the key to its end. Others say the opposite, namely, that being Jewish is the key to its survival.

This is no small matter.

There is no question but that much demonization and slander of Israel has to do with it going against prevailing notions, except in the Muslim world, and insisting that it be a Jewish state first and multicultural second. Even in Israel this fight is waged by the left including the courts, media and academia. They support Israel as a state like any other state and argue it should be democratic first and Jewish second. In fact they agree with Burg.

I understand that this demonization is intended to bring about Israel’s destruction either conceptually or physically. It is not about the “poor Palestinians” or about civil rights.

But the Jewish left in Israel and the US have a different agenda. They really believe that there must be equality in both civil and political rights (although they also have an animus for religion in general and religious Jews in particular). A Jewish state flies in the face of this. It leaves Israel open to charges of racism. Furthermore, the left throughout the west, including the majority of Jews, continues to embrace multiculturalism. They are for dismantling their cultures on this alter and demanding Israel do the same.

Rabbi Andrew Davis, director of Arza, the Zionist wing of the Reform Movement, now the largest movement of Jews in North America underscores this

    “Now we need to move to the next level of Zionism, which is how to build a state of equality, justice and democracy.”

    “Part of our Zionist agenda is not only to connect Reform Jews and Israel, but to impact Israeli society,”

    “Our commitment to religious justice issues, to democracy, pluralism, are tremendously important values that need to be strengthened and supported more in Israeli society. Our aliya efforts are designed to put more troops on the ground to strengthen Israel in these ways.”

Sounds messianic doesn’t it. This is the religion of the Jewish left. They fight for the rights of others. For them this is what Judaism and being Jewish is all about.

Make no mistake about it, democracy and pluralism, will deny or sap the Jewish raison d’etre. It is easy to see how the principle of equality would hamstring Israel as a Jewish state.

We on the right fight for the opposite. We do not apologize for our culture but insist on it, both in America and in Israel. We believe that fighting for our culture and winning is necessary for our survival. We are also against discrimination and for equality but we believe that we have the right to protect our culture, to give it a favoured place in Israel and to advance the ingathering of the exiles. Judaism is more than universalism. If there is a conflict between being democratic and Jewish, so be it.

Previously I wrote two articles on the subject, It pays to be Jewish and Particularism Before Universalism

Recently the Supreme Court of Israel held that Israel can’t discriminate in allocating JNF land. If this decision is allowed to stand, where does it end. Does it mean that the Law of Return also falls to the same principle. If not why not? If Israel passed a law providing Arabs with financial incentives to emigrate, would the SC hold it to be discriminatory and require that it be offered to all citizens? In many western democracies, the laws of the land are sometimes trumped by the interests of national security. In Israel too. This concept must be extended to include the protection of Israel as a Jewish state.

On an aside I would point out that the JNF could have righted the situation regarding their land by cancelling the agreement with the ILA so that the JNF managed the land. The JNF is run by liberal Jews and it declined to do this. How sad and destructive.

One of the icons of the left is affirmative action which obviously denies equality. Affirmative action is seen as making up for years of discrimination and therefor worthy. If anyone or people are entitled to affirmative action, the Jews are. I look upon the Balfour Declaration as an act of affirmative action and the recognition of the State of Israel, after the Holocaust, as another act of affirmative action. In fact, the rationale for the creation of the Israel was the need to create a refuge for Jews in recognition of two thousand years of discrimination. Jews are entitled to this assistance or favouritism or protection whatever you may call it. We paid for it in blood.

Posted by Ted Belman @ 8:00 am | 36 Comments »

Comments are closed.

Israpundit Digest

Support Israpundit





Blog Traffic

Pages|Hits |Unique

  • Last 24 hours: 31,823
  • Last 7 days: 149,883
  • Last 30 days: 367,185
  • Online now: 109
Los Angeles SEO
Current Entries

Recent Comments

  • Palestinian Deception and the Unwarranted Trust of the West: The Case of Palestinian Accession to International Conventions (1)

    • bernard ross: specifically the United Nations and the governments of...

  • The Jewish Question (3)

    • bernard ross: @ Amoton: I beleive this is a false flag as Putin basically...

    • Amoton: The N(a)zi’s are back! Jews ordered to “register”...

    • AbbaGuutuu: By and large, orthodox Jews voted for McCain in 2008 and for...

  • Steve Goldberg: The Only Viable Option (39)

    • bernard ross: Its interesting to see that Israel only considers diplomatic...

    • bernard ross: It is interesting to watch all these attempts to figure out...

    • bernard ross: CuriousAmerican Said: If one wants to effect peace with a...

    • mikewise: there are many aspects to the post annexation status of the arabs...

    • Bear Klein: @ Steve Goldberg: A plan must actually be a plan (e.g. goal,...

  • No To Unconditional Citizenship! (2)

    • Yidvocate: The first step should be to abolish the Oslo Accords as the...

  • ‘The Temple Mount Has Been Occupied By Hamas’ (6)

    • mar55: HB my daughter was saying if things get too bad i Bethesda, Texas is...

    • honeybee: mar55 Said: Round ‘em up, move “em out You want me to send you some...

    • mar55: @ keelie: Round ‘em up, move “em out…....

  • Donetsk leaflet: Jews must register or face deportation (17)

    • ArnoldHarris: @ bernard ross: That’s my take on this as well. The...

    • bernard ross: Ted: the automatic scrolling where text goes out of the text...

    • bernard ross: mar55 Said: false flag or not this is 1938 all over again I...

  • European Jewry is Doing What Hitler Couldn’t (17)
  • Can Israel be both Jewish and democratic (213)

    • dove: @ dweller: Anybody who can read can properly interpret. Jews are every...

  • Muslim Brotherhood launches its own U.S. political party (1)

    • CuriousAmerican: You may be looking at this the wrong way. Islamist, and...


Fair Use

This site may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of political, human rights, economic, democracy, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research, educational, or satirical purposes. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Site Membership

Google Site Search


    Ted Belman


    News and Views on Israel, the Middle East, the war on terror and the clash of civilizations.


Will Israel attack Iran

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...



Iran islam



Daily Archives

April 2014
« Mar    

Selected Israpundit Articles


Miscellaneous Info

    All Politic Sites