Israpundit Digest

Support Israpundit


USD

ILS

CAD

Syndication

Blog Traffic

Pages

Pages|Hits |Unique

  • Last 24 hours: 0
  • Last 7 days: 0
  • Last 30 days: 0
  • Online now: 0
Los Angeles SEO

Recent Comments

Sponsors

Sponsor

Dry Bones
Dry Bones

”souvenirs”

Archives

Fair Use

This site may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of political, human rights, economic, democracy, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research, educational, or satirical purposes. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

LIVE HEADLINE NEWS FEEDS
THERE IS NO DIPLOMATIC SOLUTION

Support Israpundit

USD

ILS

CND


  • February 5, 2013

    A Study in False Moral Equivalence

    by Jonathan S. Tobin”, COMMENTYARY

    The New York Timereports today that a new study is attempting to downplay the role that incitement to hatred in Palestinian schools is playing in fueling the conflict. The study is the product of the Council of Religious Institutions of the Holy Land, a left-leaning ecumenical group that is partially financed by a grant from the U.S. State Department. The group claims as its goal to promote peace and understanding and their study’s conclusion purports to be as even-handed as their approach to peace.


    But the report’s claim that there is a rough moral equivalence between the attitudes of the Israeli and Palestinian education systems toward the promotion of hate is so far removed from reality as to render it useless as a measure of the problem. That study, which was rejected by a number of the academics who were part of the group commissioned to analyze the issue, must therefore be considered a contribution to the propaganda war against Israel rather than an effort to pave the way for accord between the two peoples.

    As the Times noted:

    Arnon Groiss, another Israeli member of the advisory panel, an Arabist, and the researcher and author of many previous reports critical of the Palestinian Authority textbooks, also refused to endorse the report, saying last week that he had not seen a final version. But he insisted that the authority’s textbooks “prepare the pupils for a future armed struggle for the elimination of the state of Israel.”

     

    To seize on two points brought up in the Times article highlights the dishonesty of such a conclusion. The report claims that both school systems publish textbooks with maps that do not always show the other side’s claims. In practice this means that some Israeli books have maps that do not show the “green line” that marks the border between the West Bank and pre-1967 Israel while all Palestinian books depict both Israel and the territories as the state of Palestine.

    That sounds like the same thing but it really isn’t. Israeli books depict the reality that the Jewish state does have control over the entire area. Asking them to show maps that show a state of Palestine that doesn’t already exist is absurd. On the other hand, what the Palestinians are showing not only contradicts reality but also shows their dream of destroying Israel.

    The other example is even more egregious. The Times skims over the fact that the supposedly moderate Palestinian Authority honors suicide bombers and other terrorists not just in schools but also in other venues. But it then compares this to the way Israeli schools honor the memory of Josef Trumpeldor, the hero of the defense of Tel Hai. Trumpeldor famously said after being fatally wounded that “Never mind, it’s good to die for our country.” The report compares this to the ethos of suicide bombers but the difference is that Trumpeldor died fighting to defend Jews from slaughter at the hands of Arab attackers, not deliberately sacrificing his life in order to kill innocents as the terrorists do.

    It needs to be understood that the research on Palestinian education and media is voluminous and has left little doubt about the fact that the PA uses the schools as well as TV and radio to promote a nationalist spirit that sees the Jews as interlopers in the land which must be cleansed of their presence. If that has changed, there needs to be evidence that is not forthcoming. By contrast, peace education has been an integral part of the curriculum in Israeli schools since the beginning of the Oslo process 20 years ago. That means any assertion that there is any comparison between what is going on in the schools seems to hinge on the idea that telling the truth about the Palestinians will undermine the tenuous hope for peace.

    This kind of thinking is similar to the mistakes made by both the United States government and some Israeli leaders who spent the 1990s ignoring Palestinian violations of the peace accords because they thought holding them accountable would derail negotiations. But, as veteran peace processor Dennis Ross later admitted, this was a cardinal error that only encouraged the Palestinians to trash any hope of peace and led to the violence of the second intifada.

    The point here is not just that this report is wrongheaded but that it undermines hopes for peace rather than encouraging them. True interfaith understanding rests on facing the facts about the two different cultures, not pretending they are both the same when the differences are so powerful.

  • Posted by Ted Belman @ 2:14 pm | 7 Comments »

    7 Comments to A Study in False Moral Equivalence

    1. the phoenix says:

      @curious american

      But the report’s claim that there is a rough moral equivalence between the attitudes of the Israeli and Palestinian education systems toward the promotion of hate is so far removed from reality as to render it useless as a measure of the problem

      It’s ok american, you can fess up. It WAS you that wrote this report, wasn’t it?

    2. Canadian Otter says:

      Columnists who are now furiously writing about this report should take note. Textbooks used by Arabs in the PA, Gaza and Jerusalem have been denounced by activists for many years – to no avail. They even provided translations for government officials. No reaction. The Israeli government has so far failed to demand a stop to their incitement. Government attitude has been one of silence, indifference, and sometimes outright support.

      Israel Supports Palestinian Incitement – Officials in the White House explained that Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu had asked the U.S. to continue providing aid to the PA, including to PA schools and to UNRWA, one of the primary sources of incitement. – http://www.israpundit.com/archives/41179

      Jewish lives are not only threatened by guns, but by Arab hateful indoctrination of their children. The mind of every PA/Gaza terrorist and murderer has been nurtured in their factories of hate and terror: schools and television programs funded by the West and supported by the government of Israel.

    3. Dean says:

      Do you ever get the feeling that those who endlessly pick away at the little scab known as the Arab-Israel conflict do not have the sense to treat the Islamist cancer spreading rapidly throughout the world body?

    4. C.R. says:

      Council of Religious Institutions of the Holy Land–is a [cultural] Marxist organization.

    5. C.R. says:

      @ Canadian Otter:

      Jewish lives are not only threatened by guns, but by Arab hateful indoctrination of their children. The mind of every PA/Gaza terrorist and murderer has been nurtured in their factories of hate and terror: schools and television programs funded by the West and supported by the government of Israel.

      True!

    6. Honey Bee says:

      @ the phoenix:

      Do you believe me Or your lying eyes? Texas dicha [saying]

    7. CuriousAmerican says:

      @ the phoenix:
      It’s ok american, you can fess up. It WAS you that wrote this report, wasn’t it?

      Ha! Ha!

      I would never have equated Trumpledor (a genuine hero) with a suicide bomber of civilians.

      There are many times I have excoriated Arab crimes.

      That sounds like the same thing but it really isn’t. Israeli books depict the reality that the Jewish state does have control over the entire area. Asking them to show maps that show a state of Palestine that doesn’t already exist is absurd. On the other hand, what the Palestinians are showing not only contradicts reality but also shows their dream of destroying Israel.

      That is double talk. Both sides have denied the existence of the other’s claims. Frankly, Many of those Israeli maps show the dream of many Jews of destroying any nascent Palestinian state. Many of those Jews post on this website. So there is an equivalence. It is double talk to deny the equivalence.

      Certainly a functional equivalence, not necessarily morally equivalent.

      I do not get too upset at that equivalence since I am not in favor of the two state solution but instead I suggest either:

      A) Paying the young Palestinians to leave
      B) enfranchising those who don’t leave

      But both sides deny the claims of the other. They are functionally equivalent, if not morally equivalent when it comes to maps.

      The difference is that Israel has a moral claim on Judea and Samaria.

      However, both sides do deny the right of the other to exist as a nation state.

      It is folly to deny an equivalence where it exists. Rather than deny the obvious equivalence, admit it and explain why you think it is called for.

      Both sides deny the other the right to exist politically on the land.

      Israel may have more justification; but even so, both side deny the other’s right to exist.

    Site Membership



    Google Site Search

    Editor

      Ted Belman

      tbelman3-at-gmail.com

    Mission

      News and Views on Israel, the Middle East, the war on terror and the clash of civilizations.

    Polls

    Will Israel attack Iran

    View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...

    RECOMMENDED BOOKS

    LOVE




    Tolerism2

    Iran islam

    Sharing

    mandate4

    Daily Archives

    July 2014
    S M T W T F S
    « Jun    
     12345
    6789101112
    13141516171819
    20212223242526
    2728293031  

    Selected Israpundit Articles

    Miscellaneous Info

      All Politic Sites